Issues

Can you prove it? One Christian looks at the evidence for the Christian faith.

God in Creation - 'Irreducible Complexity'

ISSUES-ENVRI-WORLD

These pages have been produced by David Couchman MA (Cantab), MSc. The material is taken from the Facing the Challenge course, and is used with permission.

The theory of Evolution was first widely popularised and given a plausible mechanism in Charles Darwin’s ‘Origin of Species’ (1859). We can think of evolution as the mechanism by which all the different forms of life arose from non-living matter, by natural processes.

Over the past hundred and forty years, it has often been argued that evolution can explain the origins of life, including human life, without resorting to belief in a designer or creator. Thus the theory of evolution (which is supposedly a scientific theory capable of being proved or disproved by evidence) has often been co-opted as an argument against faith in God.

Michael Behe is professor of Biochemistry at Leigh University in the USA. His recent book, ‘Darwin’s Black Box’ challenges received orthodoxy about evolution at the biochemical level. Behe uses ‘black box’ as a term for something that looks simple from the outside, but its inner workings – how it does what it does – are mysterious or unknown.

Behe says that in Darwin’s day, the cell was a black box. The technology just did not exist then to answer questions about how life worked at the biochemical level.

He says that for more than a hundred years, the academic establishment has overwhelmingly accepted Darwin’s proposal that life can be explained in terms of natural selection working on random variations, even though the basic mechanisms of life were a black box. However, in recent years, scientists have come to understand much more about how life works at the biochemical level, and the result is a challenge to Darwin’s theory.

In the past, Behe says, scientists assumed that the biochemical basis of life was very simple. But the more they have discovered, the more complicated it proves to be. The result of discoveries in biochemistry since the 1950s is to show that life is based on complicated molecular machines. Behe says that for Darwin’s theory of evolution to be true, it has to be able to account for the molecular structure of life – and the purpose of his book is to show that the theory can’t do this.

Behe has identified a number of biochemical systems that he says are ‘irreducibly complex’. An irreducibly complex system is one made of well matched interacting parts that all contribute to the basic function. Take any one of them away, and the whole system stops working. A mouse-trap is an example of an irreducibly complex system – if you take any single part away, the trap doesn’t work, and the mouse escapes. Behe says that such irreducibly complex biochemical systems could not be formed by a series of small changes, because the intermediate systems wouldn’t work.

In his book, Behe gives a number of examples worked out in detail, including the mechanism of blood clotting, cellular transport mechanisms, antibody defence against disease, and the cilium – a whip-like structure that some cells use to swim with.

How could such complex biochemical systems have been produced gradually? What are the intermediate stages by which they might have developed and how could they have moved from one stage to another? According to Behe, there are no answers. There is, he says, ‘an eerie silence’ in the scientific literature about how such biochemical machines developed. There are no academic papers showing how such complex biochemical systems could have evolved by a series of small random changes.

Behe’s argument is that the existence of irreducibly complex systems is evidence for design in nature. The result of massive efforts by biochemists to investigate life at the molecular level is a loud, clear, piercing cry of ‘design!’ He goes on to say that the conclusion of intelligent design flows naturally from the data itself, and not from what he calls ‘sacred books or sectarian beliefs.’

It is important to note that the argument from irreducible complexity is not the same as an argument that evolution does not happen. (Of course, Christians remain deeply divided between a literal ‘Creationist’ understanding of Genesis and a metaphorical ‘theistic evolution’ understanding.) Rather, this is an argument that whether or not evolution happens, intelligent design is needed to account for the way we are made. The irreducible complexity argument is an argument against the kind of un-directed, random evolution that has so often been used to rule out belief in a designer and creator.

It is also important to understand that, whereas the anthropic principle is widely recognised by cosmologists and physicists, the argument from irreducible complexity is largely the work of one man, and has not found wide acceptance by biologists and biochemists.

Bookmark

Related Items

Can you prove it? One Christian looks at the evidence for the Christian faith.

Evidence from History - the Old Testament Scriptures

  • Issues
  • Text
bible-ot

Can you prove it? One Christian looks at the evidence for the Christian faith.

Evidence from History - the Old Testament Scriptures

  • Issues
  • Text

These pages have been produced by David Couchman MA (Cantab), MSc. The material is taken from the Facing the Challenge course, and is used with permission.  The Old Testament Points to Christ An important piece of evidence to whether the Christian faith can be proven […]

Can you prove it? One Christian looks at the evidence for the Christian faith.

Evidence from Archaeology - scriptural references

  • Issues
  • Text
P&P-CHURCH HISTORY-JERUSALEM

Can you prove it? One Christian looks at the evidence for the Christian faith.

Evidence from Archaeology - scriptural references

  • Issues
  • Text

These pages have been produced by David Couchman MA (Cantab), MSc. The material is taken from the Facing the Challenge course, and is used with permission.  Official Titles in the Book of Acts The book of Acts covers the beginning of the life of the […]

BIBLE- EVIDENCE-Archelogical dig

Can you prove it? One Christian looks at the evidence for the Christian faith.

Evidence from Archaeology

  • Issues
  • Text

These pages have been produced by David Couchman MA (Cantab), MSc. The material is taken from the Facing the Challenge course, and is used with permission.  Archaeological Confirmation of the New Testament Records Introduction Jesus was probably crucified in spring AD 30. In ‘Are the […]

Can you prove it? One Christian looks at the evidence for the Christian faith.

Evidence from History - The New Testament Documents

  • Issues
  • Text
BIBLE-EVIDENCE-DSS

Can you prove it? One Christian looks at the evidence for the Christian faith.

Evidence from History - The New Testament Documents

  • Issues
  • Text

These pages have been produced by David Couchman MA (Cantab), MSc. The material is taken from the Facing the Challenge course, and is used with permission.  The Reliability of the New Testament Documents How sure can we be that what we read is what the […]

Jesus Teaching_13

Can you prove it? One Christian looks at the evidence for the Christian faith.

Evidence from History - Josephus

  • Issues
  • Text

These pages have been produced by David Couchman MA (Cantab), MSc. The material is taken from the Facing the Challenge course, and is used with permission.  Josephus Josephus was a Jewish historian. He wrote around the end of the first century, and his two most […]

  • Issues
  • Text
Salvation

Can you prove it? One Christian looks at the evidence for the Christian faith.

Evidence from History - The Babylonian Talmud

  • Issues
  • Text

These pages have been produced by David Couchman MA (Cantab), MSc. The material is taken from the Facing the Challenge course, and is used with permission.  The Babylonian Talmud The Talmuds were Rabbinic commentaries on the Jewish scriptures. The Babylonian Talmud was probably completed around […]

P&P-CHURCH HISTORY-NERO

Can you prove it? One Christian looks at the evidence for the Christian faith.

Evidence from History

  • Issues
  • Text

These pages have been produced by David Couchman MA (Cantab), MSc. The material is taken from the Facing the Challenge course, and is used with permission.  When asking the question of the Christian faith, ‘Can you prove it?’ Amongst the most important evidence is the […]

  • Issues
  • Text
BIBLE-OT-CREATION-LIGHT

Can you prove it? One Christian looks at the evidence for the Christian faith.

God in Creation - summary of the arguments.

  • Issues
  • Text

These pages have been produced by David Couchman MA (Cantab), MSc. The material is taken from the Facing the Challenge course, and is used with permission. Many people today believe that we are just animals – humans are not really any different from hamsters. However, […]

  • Issues
  • Text
BIBLE-OT-CREATION-DAY3

Can you prove it? One Christian looks at the evidence for the Christian faith.

God in Creation - The 'Anthropic Principle'

  • Issues
  • Text

These pages have been produced by David Couchman MA (Cantab), MSc. The material is taken from the Facing the Challenge course, and is used with permission. Who is not amazed when they look up at the stars? The Bible says: ‘The heavens tell of the […]

God and Suffering

If God exists why does he allow suffering?

  • Issues
  • Text
JESUS-TEACHING-FORGIVNESS

God and Suffering

If God exists why does he allow suffering?

  • Issues
  • Text

People are divided on the question of whether or not God is real. Some people believe that we are here by chance – a result of evolution; that we make our own destiny and decisions; that it is down to humankind to help each other […]

A member of Youth For Christ
A member country of International Youth For Christ